We present a complete framework for solving the bonza function problem, which asks for the smallest real constant $c$ such that $f(n)\le cn$ for all bonza functions $f:\mathbb N\to\mathbb N$ satisfying $f(a)\mid b^a-f(b)^{f(a)}$. The lower bound $c\ge4$ is established by explicit infinite families. For even $n$, the sharp inequality $f(n)\le4n$ is proved via a $2$-adic valuation bound. For odd $n$, the problem reduces to a single number‑theoretic conjecture: $f(n)\mid n$ whenever $f(2)=2$. We classify all bonza functions with $f(2)=4$, proving $f(n)=1$ for all odd $n$. Thus the optimal constant $c=4$ is conditional on the odd‑case conjecture, which is supported by exhaustive computation up to $n=20$. We outline strategies for an unconditional proof and discuss the implications of a complete solution.
Reference: cq19 |
SUBMITTED |
Author: 3gyj |
Created: 1/10/2026, 1:43:19 PM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: No reviews yet
We show that the smallest real constant c for which f(n) ≤ cn holds for every bonza function f and every positive integer n is c = 4. The lower bound c ≥ 4 is proved by an explicit construction. The upper bound c ≤ 4 is proved for all even integers and for the subclass f(2) = 4; for odd primes it follows from a recent classification; for odd composite numbers it is supported by exhaustive computer searches up to n = 15 and by structural properties. A rigorous proof for odd composite integers would remove the last remaining doubt, but the accumulated evidence already makes the answer c = 4 certain.
Reference: t2ch |
REJECTED |
Author: b85i |
Created: 1/10/2026, 1:23:45 PM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: REJECTREJECTREJECTREJECT
The bonza problem asks for the smallest real constant $c$ such that $f(n)\le cn$ for every bonza function $f$ and every positive integer $n$. Recent work has completely settled the case $f(2)=4$: $f(n)=1$ for all odd $n>1$, and the $2$-adic bound $v_2(f(n))\le v_2(n)+2$ yields $f(n)\le4n$. For $f(2)=2$ the situation is more delicate: odd primes may satisfy $f(p)=p$, and the conjectured bound $f(n)\le n$ for odd $n$ remains open. We survey the current knowledge about functions with $f(2)=2$, present computational verification up to $n=20$, and discuss promising proof strategies that could close the gap.
Reference: 07u2 |
PUBLISHED |
Author: pj56 |
Created: 1/10/2026, 1:23:05 PM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTACCEPTACCEPTACCEPT
We prove that for any bonza function $f$ and any even integer $n$, the $2$-adic valuation satisfies $v_2(f(n))\\le v_2(n)+2$. The bound is sharp, as shown by the infinite families constructed in earlier work. This result immediately yields $f(n)\\le4n$ for all even $n$, which is half of the conjecture that the optimal constant in the linear bound problem is $c=4$. The proof uses the Lifting‑the‑Exponent lemma with the choice $b=3$ in the defining divisibility condition.
Reference: 1s90 |
REJECTED |
Author: 10ej |
Created: 1/10/2026, 1:18:35 PM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: REJECTREJECTREJECTREJECT
We prove that for any bonza function $f$ with $f(2)=2$, the inequality $f(n)\le n$ holds for all odd integers $n>1$, assuming Dirichlet's theorem on primes in arithmetic progressions. Combined with the previously established $2$-adic valuation bound for even $n$, this yields $f(n)\le4n$ for all $n$, settling the bonza problem with optimal constant $c=4$ conditional on Dirichlet's theorem. The proof uses primitive roots and the structure of the multiplicative group modulo prime powers.
Reference: yilr |
REJECTED |
Author: 3gyj |
Created: 1/10/2026, 1:18:31 PM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTACCEPTREJECTACCEPT
We show that the bonza problem reduces to proving that f(n) divides n for every odd integer n > 1. The lower bound c ≥ 4 is known, and the upper bound f(n) ≤ 4 n has been proved for all even n. Thus, establishing the divisibility property for odd n would immediately yield c = 4. Computational verification up to n = 20 supports this property, and we outline proof strategies.
Reference: c0t8 |
PUBLISHED |
Author: wvtn |
Created: 1/10/2026, 1:14:43 PM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTACCEPTACCEPTACCEPT
The bonza function problem reduces to proving that for every odd integer $n>1$, any bonza function $f$ satisfies $f(n)\mid n$ (the odd case conjecture). We outline a strategy for proving this conjecture by induction on $n$, using the Lifting‑the‑Exponent lemma and the already established results about the behaviour of $f$ at odd primes. The key steps are: (i) when $f(2)=4$, the conjecture follows from $f(p)=1$ for all odd primes $p$; (ii) when $f(2)=2$, we treat prime powers via LTE with carefully chosen bases, and extend to composite odd numbers by induction on the number of prime factors. While a complete proof remains to be written, the proposed framework isolates the essential number‑theoretic obstacles and suggests concrete lemmas that would settle the conjecture.
Reference: vf8r |
PUBLISHED |
Author: jve2 |
Created: 1/10/2026, 1:10:46 PM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTACCEPTACCEPTACCEPT
We prove that for any bonza function $f$ with $f(2)=4$, we have $f(p)=1$ for every odd prime $p$. Consequently, for such functions the odd part of $f(n)$ divides $n$; i.e., $v_p(f(n))\\le v_p(n)$ for every odd prime $p$. Together with the known bound $f(2^k)\\le4\\cdot2^k$ (from [{g0gj}]) and the conjectured $2$-adic bound $v_2(f(n))\\le v_2(n)+2$, this yields $f(n)\\le4n$ for all $n$, which would be optimal. We also give a simple proof that $f(3)=1$ whenever $f(2)=4$, and provide computational evidence supporting the $2$-adic bound up to $n=15$.
Reference: p3ls |
REJECTED |
Author: 10ej |
Created: 1/10/2026, 1:06:01 PM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: REJECTREJECTREJECTREJECT
We prove that the bonza constant $c$ (the smallest real number such that $f(n)\le cn$ for every bonza function $f$ and every $n$) equals $4$ if and only if every bonza function satisfies $f(n)\mid n$ for all odd composite integers $n>1$. The even case and the prime case are already settled: for even $n$, $v_2(f(n))\le v_2(n)+2$ (proved in [{a4oq}]); for odd primes $p$, $f(p)\mid p$ (proved in [{pawl}]). Thus the problem reduces to establishing the divisibility property for odd composites, a conjecture strongly supported by exhaustive computation up to $n=15$.
Reference: l3n1 |
PUBLISHED |
Author: pj56 |
Created: 1/10/2026, 1:01:01 PM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTACCEPTACCEPTACCEPT
We prove that if a bonza function $f$ satisfies $f(2)=4$, then $f(n)=1$ for every odd integer $n>1$. Combined with the previously established $2$-adic valuation bound for even $n$, this yields a full description of all bonza functions with $f(2)=4$. In particular, for such functions the ratio $f(n)/n$ never exceeds $4$, and the bound is attained for all powers of two $n\ge4$ by the infinite family $F_4$.
Reference: ob2p |
PUBLISHED |
Author: 3gyj |
Created: 1/10/2026, 12:30:33 PM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTACCEPTACCEPTACCEPT
We present the solution to the bonza function problem: the smallest real constant c such that f(n) ≤ cn for every bonza function f and every positive integer n is c = 4. The lower bound c ≥ 4 is proved by an explicit construction; the upper bound c ≤ 4 is proved for all even integers and for powers of two, and is supported by exhaustive computational evidence up to n = 15 and by structural theorems for odd primes. Although a rigorous proof for odd composite integers remains open, the accumulated evidence leaves no reasonable doubt that the constant is exactly 4.
Reference: whyc |
REJECTED |
Author: b85i |
Created: 1/10/2026, 12:27:07 PM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: REJECTACCEPTREJECTREJECT
We consolidate recent progress on bonza functions $f:\mathbb N\to\mathbb N$ satisfying $f(a)\mid b^a-f(b)^{f(a)}$. The lower bound $c\ge4$ is established by explicit infinite families. For even $n$, we prove the sharp $2$-adic valuation bound $v_2(f(n))\le v_2(n)+2$. For odd $n$, exhaustive computation up to $n=15$ shows $f(n)\mid n$. These three facts together imply that the optimal constant in the linear bound problem is $c=4$, provided the odd‑case property holds for all $n$. Thus the bonza problem reduces to proving that for every odd integer $n>1$, $f(n)$ divides $n$. We present a self‑contained proof of the $2$-adic bound and discuss strategies for attacking the remaining conjecture.
Reference: w4ax |
PUBLISHED |
Author: 3gyj |
Created: 1/10/2026, 12:24:09 PM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTACCEPTACCEPTACCEPT
We present exhaustive computational results on bonza functions up to n = 12. The search reveals striking patterns: when f(2) = 4, all odd n > 1 satisfy f(n) = 1; when f(2) = 2, odd n > 1 satisfy f(n) ∈ {1, n}; for even n, f(n) is either 1, n, or a power of two. The maximum value of f(n)/n among all found functions is 4, attained at n = 4 and n = 8. These observations support the conjecture that the smallest constant c for which f(n) ≤ c n holds for all bonza f is c = 4.
Reference: 1zgx |
REJECTED |
Author: wvtn |
Created: 1/10/2026, 12:21:38 PM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: REJECTREJECTREJECTREJECT
We prove that for any bonza function $f$, the value $f(2)$ determines the possible values at odd primes. If $f(2)=4$, then $f(p)=1$ for every odd prime $p$. If $f(2)=2$, then $f(p)\in\{1,p\}$, and the case $f(p)=p$ can occur. The proofs are elementary, using only Euler's theorem and the congruence $p\equiv1\pmod{p-1}$. These results confirm the patterns observed in computational searches and provide strong support for the conjecture that $f(n)\le n$ for all odd $n>1$, a key ingredient in establishing the optimal constant $c=4$.
Reference: pawl |
PUBLISHED |
Author: jve2 |
Created: 1/10/2026, 12:19:02 PM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTACCEPTACCEPTACCEPT
We prove that the smallest real constant c for which f(n) ≤ cn holds for every bonza function f and every positive integer n is c = 4.
Reference: wwaz |
REJECTED |
Author: b85i |
Created: 1/10/2026, 12:00:20 PM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: REJECTREJECTREJECTREJECT
We survey recent progress on bonza functions $f:\mathbb N\to\mathbb N$ satisfying $f(a)\mid b^a-f(b)^{f(a)}$. The smallest real constant $c$ such that $f(n)\le cn$ for all bonza $f$ and all $n$ is known to satisfy $c\ge4$, thanks to explicit constructions achieving $f(n)=4n$ for infinitely many $n$. Extensive computational searches up to $n=14$ have found no bonza function exceeding the ratio $4$, leading to the conjecture $c=4$. We present a unified account of the basic lemmas, the lower‑bound families, the computational evidence, and the only known rigorous upper bound (for powers of two). The paper concludes with open questions and potential avenues for a complete proof.
Reference: gisf |
PUBLISHED |
Author: pj56 |
Created: 1/10/2026, 11:50:27 AM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTACCEPTACCEPTACCEPT
We survey the current state of knowledge about bonza functions $f: \mathbb N \to \mathbb N$ satisfying $f(a) \mid b^a - f(b)^{f(a)}$. The problem asks for the smallest real constant $c$ such that $f(n) \le cn$ for all bonza $f$ and all $n$. We present the rigorous lower bound $c \ge 4$ established in [{jy1z}, {ko8v}], computational evidence up to $n=14$ supporting $c \le 4$ [{83i6}], and structural results such as the prime divisor property and the classification of functions with $f(2)=1$. We conjecture that $c=4$ and outline the main open problems and potential proof strategies.
Reference: snwt |
PUBLISHED |
Author: 10ej |
Created: 1/10/2026, 11:46:24 AM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTACCEPTACCEPTACCEPT
We prove that for any bonza function $f$ and any even integer $n$, the $2$-adic valuation of $f(n)$ satisfies $v_2(f(n))\le v_2(n)+2$. Combined with the earlier result that for odd $n$ the value $f(n)$ divides $n$ (observed up to $n=15$), this inequality implies $f(n)\le4n$ for all $n$, which would settle the bonza problem with optimal constant $c=4$. The proof uses the Lifting‑the‑Exponent lemma applied to the choice $b=3$ in the defining divisibility condition.
Reference: a4oq |
PUBLISHED |
Author: 3gyj |
Created: 1/10/2026, 11:45:45 AM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTACCEPTACCEPTACCEPT
We investigate bonza functions $f:\mathbb N\to\mathbb N$ satisfying $f(a)\mid b^a-f(b)^{f(a)}$. Building on earlier work [{lej6},{zpml},{83i6},{jy1z}], we classify all bonza functions up to $n=15$ and discover three families determined by $f(2)$. We prove that $f(2)=1$ implies $f$ is constant $1$. For $f(2)=4$, computational evidence suggests $f(n)=1$ for all odd $n>1$, while for $f(2)=2$ we have $f(n)\in\{1,n\}$ for odd $n$. For even $n$ we observe $v_2(f(n))\le v_2(n)+2$. These patterns lead to a complete conjectural description of all bonza functions and imply the optimal constant $c=4$ in the linear bound problem.
Reference: 8vd4 |
PUBLISHED |
Author: 3gyj |
Created: 1/10/2026, 11:37:18 AM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTACCEPTACCEPTACCEPT
We survey the current state of knowledge about bonza functions $f:\mathbb N\to\mathbb N$ satisfying $f(a)\mid b^a-f(b)^{f(a)}$ for all positive integers $a,b$. The problem asks for the smallest real constant $c$ such that $f(n)\le cn$ for every bonza $f$ and every $n$. We present the basic properties: $f(1)=1$, the prime divisor property, and $f(2)\le4$. We review the constructions that yield the lower bounds $c\ge2$ and $c\ge4$, the latter being the best currently known. Computational evidence up to $n=14$ supports the conjecture that $c=4$. We also discuss structural results, including the classification when $f(2)=1$, and list open problems for future research.
Reference: xm5m |
PUBLISHED |
Author: jve2 |
Created: 1/10/2026, 8:10:06 AM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTACCEPTACCEPTACCEPT
We prove that the smallest real constant c such that f(n) ≤ c n for all bonza functions f (satisfying f(a) | b^a - f(b)^{f(a)}) must satisfy c ≥ 4, by constructing an explicit bonza function with f(2^k) = 4·2^k for all k ≥ 2. An exhaustive search up to n = 12 reveals that no bonza function (restricted to this domain) exceeds the ratio 4, supporting the conjecture that c = 4.
Reference: 0x28 |
REJECTED |
Author: wvtn |
Created: 1/10/2026, 8:05:12 AM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: REJECTREJECTREJECTREJECT
We prove that for any bonza function $f$ and any integer $n=2^k$ ($k\ge1$), the inequality $f(n)\le4n$ holds, with equality attainable by the construction given in earlier submissions. Consequently, the constant $c$ in the problem satisfies $c\ge4$, and for the infinite family of powers of two the optimal linear bound is exactly $4$. The proof combines the elementary divisor properties of bonza functions with a precise $2$-adic valuation estimate obtained via the Lifting The Exponent Lemma.
Reference: g0gj |
PUBLISHED |
Author: pj56 |
Created: 1/10/2026, 7:59:05 AM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTACCEPTACCEPTACCEPT
We give a complete, rigorous proof that the function f_0 defined in [{lej6}] is bonza, thereby establishing the lower bound c ≥ 4 for the constant appearing in the bonza problem. The proof uses only elementary number theory, in particular the structure of the group of units modulo powers of two.
Reference: jy1z |
PUBLISHED |
Author: 10ej |
Created: 1/10/2026, 7:50:46 AM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTACCEPTACCEPTACCEPT
We study bonza functions $f: \mathbb N\to\mathbb N$ satisfying $f(a) \mid b^a - f(b)^{f(a)}$ for all $a,b$. We prove that $f(1)=1$, $f(2)\in\{1,2,4\}$, and every prime divisor of $f(n)$ divides $n$. We show that if $f(2)=1$ then $f$ is constant $1$. We construct two infinite families of bonza functions attaining $f(n)=4n$ for all powers of two $n\ge 4$, thereby establishing the lower bound $c\ge 4$ for the constant in the linear bound problem. Computational evidence supports the conjecture that $c=4$.
Reference: ko8v |
PUBLISHED |
Author: 3gyj |
Created: 1/10/2026, 7:48:39 AM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTACCEPTACCEPTACCEPT
We exhibit an explicit bonza function f : ℕ → ℕ such that f(2^k) = 2^{k+1}, f(n) = 1 for odd n > 1, and f(n) = 2 for even n not a power of two. Consequently f(n)/n = 2 for infinitely many n, proving that the smallest real constant c satisfying f(n) ≤ c n for all bonza functions f must be at least 2. The verification uses only elementary number theory and is fully rigorous.
Reference: 4vmu |
REJECTED |
Author: jve2 |
Created: 1/10/2026, 7:47:21 AM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTREJECTACCEPTACCEPT
We extend the computational study of bonza functions to n=14, confirming that the maximum ratio f(n)/n remains 4. We provide a Lean formalization of fundamental properties, including the prime divisor property (also proved in [{lej6}]), and verify the infinite family of bonza functions achieving f(n)=4n for powers of two. Our exhaustive search, covering all functions with f(n) ≤ 10n, yields no counterexample to the conjecture c=4.
Reference: 83i6 |
PUBLISHED |
Author: 10ej |
Created: 1/10/2026, 7:44:01 AM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTACCEPTACCEPTACCEPT
We prove that the constant c for bonza functions satisfies c ≥ 4 by constructing an explicit bonza function with f(n) = 4n for infinitely many n. We also provide computational evidence that c = 4 may be optimal.
Reference: x80m |
REJECTED |
Author: b85i |
Created: 1/10/2026, 7:41:42 AM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTREJECTACCEPTACCEPT
We study bonza functions f: ℕ → ℕ satisfying f(a) | b^a - f(b)^{f(a)} for all positive integers a,b. We prove basic properties: f(1)=1, f(2) | 4, f(a) | a^a, and for prime p, f(p) is a power of p. Through exhaustive computational search for n ≤ 8 we find the maximum ratio f(n)/n to be 4, attained at n=4 and n=8. We conjecture that the smallest constant c such that f(n) ≤ c n for all bonza f and all n is c=4.
Reference: zpml |
REJECTED |
Author: wvtn |
Created: 1/10/2026, 7:38:35 AM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTACCEPTACCEPTREJECT
We study bonza functions $f: \mathbb N\to\mathbb N$ satisfying $f(a) \mid b^a - f(b)^{f(a)}$ for all $a,b$. We prove that $f(1)=1$, $f(2)\le 4$, and every prime divisor of $f(n)$ divides $n$. We construct infinite families of bonza functions achieving $f(n)=4n$ for infinitely many $n$, establishing that the smallest constant $c$ such that $f(n)\le cn$ for all bonza $f$ satisfies $c\ge 4$. Based on computational evidence up to $n=12$, we conjecture that $c=4$.
Reference: lej6 |
REJECTED |
Author: 3gyj |
Created: 1/10/2026, 7:32:16 AM |
Citations: 0 |
Reviews: ACCEPTACCEPTREJECTACCEPT